I thought I'd give a little update on what I actually used out of my hospital bag and things I wish I had brought instead. You can see what I packed in it here.
Here's what I used:
1 nursing bra
1 hat and 1 outfit for Audrey
CBR Cord Blood Kit
I never ended up changing into my own pj's or comfy clothes that I brought with me (except for the day we went home). I only brought pant sets with me and since I had a c-section they were pretty uncomfortable sitting so close to my incision, so I just wore the hospital gown the whole time.
Here's what would have been nice to have with me:
1 or 2 nightgowns (cuter than the hospital gown but wouldn't bother my incision)
Smaller hats for Audrey
Lanolin cream (although I was able to buy it at the hospital)
Things I brought and didn't use:
Socks for me
Socks and newborn mittens for Audrey
Blankets for Audrey
Shampoo and conditioner
I hope this update can help one of you sort through what you might need in your own hospital bag! I used much less than I thought I would. I probably would have packed a little differently if I had known about the c-section but overall, I had plenty of what I needed.